Originally published:
Published on BreakingExpress:

By Muhammad Bahrul Ulum
Queensland University of Technology, Australia

M Nurul Fajri
Andalas University, Indonesia

Torik Abdul Aziz Wibowo
Universitas Brawijaya, Indonesia

“Gibran’s words, constitutional consequences..” originally published on 360info on November 16, 2026. Licensed under CC BY 4.0. Text-only republication; media omitted and formatting sanitized.

One phrase in Gibran’s letter could shape Indonesia’s vice-presidential transition and its constitutional process.

On 12 November 2026, Indonesian Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka reportedly submitted a letter to the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) announcing that he would leave office. The move followed an impeachment motion backed by 120 members of the House of Representatives (DPR) after a court ruling invalidated the equivalency of his high school qualifications.

The MPR has since scheduled a plenary session on 2 December to appoint his successor. Under the prevailing interpretation of the law, President Prabowo Subianto must submit two candidates before the assembly can make its choice.

At first glance, the transition appears straightforward. Yet a single word in Gibran’s letter could have important implications for how Indonesia’s Constitution is applied.

Rather than using the phrase mengundurkan diri (resign), Gibran reportedly used the word berhenti (cease serving). That distinction may seem semantic. In Indonesia’s constitutional framework, however, the difference between berhenti (cease to serve), mengundurkan diri (resign) and diberhentikan (be dismissed) carries distinct legal consequences.

Different words, different processes

Public reporting has largely described Gibran’s departure as a resignation. But the wording contained in his letter raises a more complicated constitutional question.

Under Indonesia’s 1945 Constitution and Legislative Bodies Law, mengundurkan diri, berhenti, and diberhentikan are not interchangeable terms.

Mengundurkan diri refers to a voluntary act by an office-holder. A president or vice president who chooses this route resigns from office by personal decision. This phrase is only outlined in the Legislative Bodies Law, not in the Constitution, so the higher-ranking law prevails. Diberhentikan, meanwhile, refers to removal through a formal constitutional process. The term implies institutional action rather than individual choice.

Berhenti occupies a more ambiguous position. In everyday Indonesian, it simply means to stop or cease. In the constitutional context, however, it often describes the outcome of a legal process rather than the declaration that begins one. For instance, Article 8 (1) of the 1945 Constitution adopts berhenti only for presidential succession, which enables the Vice President to replace the President, but not the other way around. The Constitution does not allow the Vice President to “berhenti”, except when both the President and Vice President resign together.

Gibran’s choice to use the term berhenti suggests several possible interpretations. First, he appears to replicate Suharto’s approach on 21 May 1998: unilaterally declaring his resignation to bypass the MPR’s impeachment process.

Second, his understanding of Indonesian socio-political behaviour. Scholars have widely documented that Indonesians tend to respond to conflict with empathy, which he may use to portray himself as a victim of political hostility. He therefore claimed that his decision to berhenti was unrelated to his certificate and expressed willingness to prove his qualifications up to a bachelor’s degree.

Third, a possible strategy to pressure Prabowo to step down as well, since Article 8(3) only allows the Vice President to berhenti when the President also steps down.

That distinction matters because Indonesia’s legal framework appears to envisage different procedures for each pathway. While impeachment proceedings may end if an office-holder mengundurkan diri, the concepts of berhenti and diberhentikan are more closely connected to the completion of constitutional procedures.

This raises an important question: should Gibran’s letter be interpreted as a resignation, or does the use of berhenti require the constitutional process to continue before his departure can formally take effect?

If the latter interpretation prevails, the impeachment process would need to proceed through the Constitutional Court before returning to the MPR for a final decision. Only then would the vice presidency become formally vacant and the succession process move forward.

 A legacy of Reformasi

The significance of this debate can only be understood in the context of Indonesia’s constitutional reforms after the fall of Suharto.

Before the constitutional amendments adopted between 1999 and 2002, the Constitution provided limited guidance on how a president or vice president could be removed from office. When Suharto announced in 1998 that he would berhenti, the constitutional framework offered considerable room for interpretation.

The post-Reformasi amendments sought to remove that ambiguity.

Articles 7A and 7B established a structured impeachment mechanism and gave the Constitutional Court a central role in reviewing attempts to remove a president or vice president from office. The reforms were intended to ensure that such decisions would not be determined solely by political calculations but would also undergo legal scrutiny.

This reflected a broader effort to strengthen the rule of law after decades in which questions of political power were often settled outside clear constitutional procedures.

From that perspective, the issue today is not merely whether Gibran wishes to leave office. It is whether the constitutional safeguards introduced after Reformasi should still operate when a vice president chooses to step aside amid an impeachment process.

Why the process matters

The constitutional route is significant because it would require the allegations against Gibran to be tested through legal proceedings.

A Constitutional Court review would likely examine the issues underlying the impeachment motion, including questions surrounding the validity of his educational documents. This would differ from earlier legal proceedings involving his qualifications, which focused primarily on electoral matters rather than constitutional removal from office.

If the court found insufficient grounds for impeachment, Gibran could remain vice president. If it found the allegations sufficient, the process would move to the MPR for a final determination.

The constitutional mechanism was designed precisely for situations in which competing claims about a public official must be assessed through a formal legal process rather than through political narratives alone.

Viewed in this light, the debate is no longer simply about whether Gibran will leave office. It is about whether berhenti can substitute for mengundurkan diri within Indonesia’s post-Reformasi constitutional framework.

Beyond law, a political question

The legal significance of Gibran’s wording is only one dimension of the story. The choice of language may also influence how his departure is understood politically.

Soon after submitting the letter, Gibran publicly stated that his decision was unrelated to the controversy surrounding his educational credentials. He also maintained that he remained willing to defend the authenticity of those qualifications.

Those statements create an interesting tension. On one hand, Gibran has expressed confidence in his documentation. On the other, leaving office before the impeachment process runs its course removes the possibility of those claims being tested through the constitutional mechanism established for that purpose.

Supporters may see his departure as a voluntary political decision. Critics may argue that it leaves important questions unresolved. Either way, the language used to describe his exit will likely shape public perceptions of what has occurred.

This is particularly important in Indonesia’s highly personalised political environment, where narratives surrounding political victories and defeats often outlive the legal disputes that produce them.

Whether Gibran’s use of berhenti was intended primarily as a legal choice, a political choice or both remains open to interpretation. What is clear is that the distinction between berhenti, mengundurkan diri and diberhentikan is more than a matter of wording.

In a constitutional system built on procedure, words matter. And in this case, one word may influence not only how Indonesia’s vice-presidential transition unfolds, but also how the country’s constitutional safeguards are understood and applied.

Muhammad Bahrul Ulum is a PhD scholar at the School of Law, Queensland University of Technology, Australia and an assistant professor at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Brawijaya, Indonesia.

M Nurul Fajri is an assistant professor in the Constitutional Law Department and a researcher at the Centre for Constitutional Studies (PUSaKO), Faculty of Law, Andalas University, Indonesia.

Torik Abdul Aziz Wibowo is an assistant professor at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Brawijaya, Indonesia.

Originally published under Creative Commons by 360info.

The post Gibran’s words, constitutional consequences.. appeared first on 360.

Source: 360info