Originally published:
Published on BreakingExpress:

By Dan Romer

“Motor vehicle crash fatalities and injuries among young people: What journalists need to know” originally published on The Journalist’s Resource on November 17, 2026. Licensed under CC BY-ND 4.0. Text-only republication; media omitted and formatting sanitized.

Motor vehicle crashes are a major preventable cause of death and serious injury among adolescents and young adults in the U.S. There were 2,162 young drivers aged 15 to 20 who died in crashes on U.S. roads in 2024, the most recent year of data available. Another 184,129 were injured.

Young driver fatalities and injuries are dramatically lower than they were in 1975, when the U.S. first started systematically tracking fatal crashes. Declines in crashes can be attributed to improvements in road safety, vehicle safety and occupant protection, such as seat belts.

Policies and legislation aimed at driver safety have also helped, including graduated licensing and the 1984 National Minimum Drinking Age Act.

But the curve has flattened — and, recently, moved in the wrong direction. Since 2019 there has been a 21% increase in crash fatalities among young drivers.

This pattern tells us two things:

  • Prevention works.
  • The strategies that brought us this far are insufficient to prevent an unacceptable number of teen injuries and deaths.
U.S. crashes among teenagers
Infogram

Teen drivers crash because of specific preventable errors

Some people may think of reckless behavior when they think about teen driver crashes: behaviors like drug and alcohol use, or thrill seeking.

But scientific evidence reveals that teens tend to crash because of three critical errors:

  • Inadequate scanning and hazard detection.
  • Driving too fast for road conditions.
  • Distraction.

These errors are often related to lack of experience driving under different conditions.

As we have discovered in our research, crashes cluster in recurring scenarios: stopped traffic, left turns, and curves and road departures.

In our analysis, these scenarios account for more than a third of serious crashes. Some adolescents may also have less fully developed attention skills that make them more susceptible to distraction or failure to notice potential hazards. As teens gain more experience driving independently, their risk of crashes declines. Risky behavior and peer influence certainly contribute to crash risk, but a major reason why teens crash in their early licensed days is because they haven’t yet fully learned how to drive safely.

States vary widely in what they require of young drivers

Since the 1990s, states have turned to graduated driver licensing as their major policy response for improving the safety of young drivers. Graduated licensing programs restrict adolescent drivers, typically ages 15 to 17, from driving at night and under other high-risk conditions. These programs also tend to require supervised driving during a learner period before a young driver can get an intermediate license.

Supervised driving can take the form of adult-supervised practice, where a learner driver is required to obtain a certain number of practice hours with an adult, typically a parent, age 21 or older. There are 44 states that require a certain number of hours of adult-supervised practice.

Around two-thirds of states also require behind-the-wheel training from a professional driving instructor, either in addition to or in place of adult-supervised practice. In most states, applicants first licensed at age 18 are exempt from some or all requirements and restrictions that apply to younger applicants, though some states have recently extended those requirements up to age 21.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety is the most up-to-date source of graduated licensing requirements in the U.S., though its reporting does not track behind-the-wheel requirements.

Ohio is one state that combines graduated driver licensing restrictions with adult-supervised practice and professional behind-the-wheel training requirements. Our research there associated those requirements with greater driving skill at the time of licensure in 16- and 17-year olds compared with drivers age 18 and older. Ohio has now extended adult-supervised practice and behind-the-wheel training requirements to drivers under age 21.

(The research did not clearly isolate the role of professional training in developing driving skill.)

Younger drivers in the study were also more likely to pass an on-road exam on their first try than older applicants. When we followed newly licensed drivers over the next several years, we found 16- and 17-year-olds tended to experience fewer crashes during their early years of independent driving than 18-year-olds who were not required to obtain training.

This pattern is also evident in the higher national fatal crash rates of young drivers ages 18 to 24.

Nevertheless, it is difficult to disentangle the effects of training from other factors that are unaccounted for, such as age-related differences in driving exposure — it may be that 16- and 17-year-olds crash less because they drive less, or tend to drive under less hazardous conditions.

And while comparisons across states find an association between stricter graduated driver licensing requirements — like driver training — and lower teen crash rates, those comparisons do not account for the vast differences in road conditions and driving culture across states.

We need more evidence on the types of preparation that are most effective

To that end, our research team is conducting the DRIVER study, a randomized trial in the Philadelphia area. Adolescents ages 16 and 17 agree to be assigned at random to one of three learning experiences:

  • Six hours of behind-the-wheel training.
  • Approximately two hours of an online hazard-skills training.
  • An active control group.

Pennsylvania is a good environment for testing the effects of professional behind-the-wheel training.

New teen drivers there are required to complete 65 hours of adult-supervised practice but no professional behind-the-wheel training. We intend to determine whether obtaining behind-the-wheel training improves driving preparation and crash risk during that critical period from the learner phase to intermediate driving.

Importantly, we are using a smartphone application to capture telematics — similar to applications used by insurance companies — to measure how much teens drive during the first six months of independent driving. This way, we can account for driving exposure when examining differences in behind-the-wheel training. Telematics also allow us to register events related to risky driving, such as speeding, hard braking and handheld phone use.

The online training program in the DRIVER study is the ACCEL program developed by Donald Fisher, Ph.D., at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. ACCEL trains new drivers to recognize potential hazards such as hidden vehicles that may enter the road or the need to use rearview mirrors to safely merge onto highways. The program also trains drivers on the need to stay focused and not take their eyes off the road for longer than two seconds.

If such training can be successful, it could provide a less costly way to reduce crashes, or demonstrate a relatively easy way to supplement behind-the-wheel training. Other countries, such as the U.K., evaluate those skills as part of their driver licensing process.

Unequal access to driver training

Not all teen drivers receive equal access to driving preparation. Despite popular opinion that today’s teens do not want to drive, our research in Philadelphia has shown that most teens actually want to learn to drive — about 80% to 90% of them. But when we looked at who actually goes on to get their driver’s license, we see significant differences depending on where teens live.

Just under a third of teens in low-opportunity neighborhoods had driver’s permits or licenses, compared to 91% of teens in high-opportunity neighborhoods.

Professional behind-the-wheel driver training can be expensive, with a price tag of up to $83 per hour, according to one estimate. Ohio reports that teen driver training typically costs from $400 to $900 total. We have used geospatial analysis to highlight communities in Ohio we’ve identified as driver training deserts, where high poverty and long travel times overlap with limited access to licensed driver training providers.

This work was conducted in collaboration with the Ohio Traffic Safety Office, which offered a grants program to expand driver training in the state and scholarships for low-income prospective drivers.

States are beginning to expand their licensing requirements

Expansion of driver training requirements should also address cost and geographic access — but, ultimately, states are battling competing funding and safety priorities. They allocate limited highway safety resources to address problems like drunk driving and speeding prevention.

Young driver safety is a critical issue for states to address and should receive attention as new evidence is published and legislative action allows. Some states are actively updating their graduated licensing requirements. For example, a 2024 Senate bill in Missouri created legislation that will require 30 hours of classroom education and six hours of behind-the-wheel training, effective by 2027.

Virginia just expanded its requirements as well: effective 2027, new drivers age 18 to 20 will have to meet the current requirements for new drivers age 16 to 17. Colorado is also updating its requirements, effective at the start of 2027.

Professional behind-the-wheel training seems a plausible option for parents who wish to provide their teen driver with more preparation. In addition, for adolescents with more limited attention abilities, additional training may help overcome the challenges driving poses for less experienced drivers.

We look forward to the results in the next two years from our trial in Philadelphia, which will provide clearer guidance to states than is currently available. These results and other recent research can also offer insight and context to reporters covering the safety of young drivers on our roads.

The post Motor vehicle crash fatalities and injuries among young people: What journalists need to know appeared first on The Journalist’s Resource.

Source: The Journalist’s Resource