When Lyft driver Tramaine Carr transports seniors and sick sufferers to hospitals in Atlanta, she looks like each a pal and a social employee.
“When the ride is an hour or an hour and a half of mostly freeway driving, people tend to tell you what they’re going through,” she mentioned.
Drivers corresponding to Carr have grow to be a essential a part of the medical transportation system in Georgia, in addition to in Washington, D.C., Mississippi, Arizona, and elsewhere. While some sufferers use transportation corporations solely devoted to medical rides or nonemergency ambulance rides to get to their appointments, the San Francisco-based ride-hailing corporations Uber and Lyft are additionally ferrying folks to emergency rooms, kidney dialysis, most cancers care, bodily remedy, and different medical visits.
But Georgia ride-hail drivers aren’t solely serving sufferers residing in Atlanta or its sprawling suburbs. When rural Georgians are too sick to drive themselves, Uber or Lyft is commonly one of many solely methods to achieve medical care within the state capital.
Rural hospital closures in Georgia have meant folks battling most cancers and different critical diseases should now commute two or extra hours to remedy services in Atlanta, mentioned Bryan Miller, director of psychosocial help companies on the Atlanta Cancer Care Foundation, a medical observe offshoot that seeks to alleviate monetary burdens for most cancers sufferers and their households.
From April 2022 to April 2024, Lyft drivers accomplished 1000’s of rides that have been higher than 50 miles every manner and that started or ended at Atlanta-area medical remedy facilities, together with the Winship Cancer Institute of Emory University and Emory University Hospital Midtown, in keeping with Lyft.
While 75% of these journeys have been beneath 100 miles, the corporate mentioned, 21% of them have been between 100 and 200 miles and 4% have been over 200, displaying that even Georgians who stay hours away from metro Atlanta depend on the ride-hail platform to achieve medical care there.
Uber Health world head Zachary Clark declined to supply comparable ridership knowledge. Uber Health is a division of Uber that organizes medical transportation for some Medicaid and Medicare recipients, well being care employees, prescription drug supply, and others in search of reimbursement for medical-related Uber rides, according to Uber’s website.
Lyft additionally has a well being care division, providing packages corresponding to Lyft Assisted and Lyft Concierge to coordinate rides for sufferers.
Nationwide, some insurance coverage corporations and most cancers remedy facilities, plus Medicare Advantage and state Medicaid plans, pay for such ride-hailing companies, typically with the purpose of lowering missed appointments, in keeping with Krisda Chaiyachati, an adjunct assistant professor on the University of Pennsylvania medical college.
In 2024, 36% of particular person Medicare Advantage plans and 88% of particular wants plans provided transportation companies, mentioned Jeannie Fuglesten Biniek, affiliate director of Medicare coverage at KFF, the well being coverage analysis, polling, and information group that features KFF Health News. A particular wants plan supplies further advantages to Medicare recipients who’ve extreme and continual illnesses or sure different well being care wants, or who even have Medicaid.
And Medicaid — the federal-state authorities security internet insurance coverage plan for these with low incomes or disabilities — paid for as much as 4 million beneficiaries to make use of nonemergency medical transportation companies yearly from 2018 by way of 2021, in keeping with a Department of Health and Human Services report. Patients residing in rural areas used ride-hailing and different nonemergency transportation suppliers on the highest charges, the report mentioned.
The estimated complete federal and state funding in nonemergency medical transportation was roughly $5 billion in 2019, according to a study by the Texas A&M University Transportation Institute.
Even with some insurance coverage protecting journeys or charities providing experience credit, social employees say, many ailing sufferers are nonetheless left and not using a experience. Nationwide, 21% of adults with out entry to a automobile or public transit went with out wanted medical care in 2022, according to a study by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. People who lacked entry to a automobile however had entry to public transit have been much less prone to skip wanted care.
The knowledge analytics firm Geotab ranked Atlanta as tied for second worst within the nation on the subject of the accessibility of its public transportation community.
“The ability to get to a doctor’s appointment can be a barrier to care,” mentioned Rochelle Schube, a most cancers help group facilitator in Atlanta. “If I give a patient $250 in Uber cards and they live far away, that gets spent quickly.”
The indisputable fact that Uber and Lyft are more durable to return by in rural America compounds the dearth of medical entry in these areas. “When you move to rural areas — which you could argue have a higher need — you see fewer services,” Chaiyachati mentioned.
Finding drivers who’re ready and keen to supply medical transportation could be a problem. The Atlanta-based start-up MedTrans Go connects sufferers and well being care suppliers with vetted drivers, many providing wheelchair or stretcher rides, in Georgia and 16 different states. Many of its drivers have medical coaching, stroll sufferers to and from medical services or their properties, and might deal with advanced conditions for weak sufferers, mentioned Dana Weeks, the corporate’s co-founder and CEO.
The firm’s app may also dispatch on to Uber or Lyft for sufferers who don’t want specialised help, she mentioned.
Uber and Lyft journeys can save sufferers and insurers cash, costing a fraction of the everyday price for an ambulance experience, mentioned David Slusky, an economics professor on the University of Kansas who has studied the affect of ride-hailing companies on drugs.
But as an alternative of all of that, argued Timothy Crimmins, a historical past professor emeritus at Georgia State University and a former director of the varsity’s neighborhood-studies middle, one of the best resolution could be for Georgia to expand Medicaid, so extra rural hospitals would be capable to stay open and Georgians may search medical care near dwelling.
The determination by Georgia lawmakers to not settle for a federally funded growth of Medicaid has left greater than 1.4 million Georgians with out medical insurance, according to KFF — and that hurts rural hospitals when these sufferers use the medical services and can’t pay their payments. In Georgia, 10 rural hospitals have both closed or ceased their inpatient care operations since 2010, in keeping with a 2024 report from well being care guide Chartis, and 18 extra are in peril of shuttering.
Until extra sufferers are insured, Crimmins mentioned, the state ought to subsidize Uber and Lyft journeys for much less affluent Georgians who need assistance reaching medical care in Atlanta. “We might be talking about $100 to $150 round-trip,” he mentioned. “That can be subsidized.”
Still, ferrying round sufferers shouldn’t be for each ride-hail driver. Damian Durand mentioned his Chevrolet Equinox SUV is giant sufficient to accommodate a medical passenger requiring a wheelchair, however he isn’t paid further to move these with medical wants. He mentioned a few of his latest passengers in Atlanta have been Medicaid recipients with psychological well being situations or disabilities.
“It can be stressful,” he mentioned. “I do feel like Uber and Lyft are trying to catch me off guard. When I can see that the ride is going to the hospital, I try to avoid or cancel the ride.”
While Durand’s expertise with medical transport has been principally adverse, Carr loves the work and appreciates having the ability to assist older Georgians, who she mentioned typically tip her nicely. For her, ride-hail work stays possibility even when it entails medical calls.
“It’s not stressful for me,” she mentioned. “I worked a good 20 years in customer service. For me, human connection is important. I tried to work from home, and I really didn’t like it. I prefer this because I can connect with people.”
Related Topics