[khn_slabs slabs=”1023554″ view=”inline” /]
[partner-box]Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar trotted out statistics on the November Democratic presidential candidates’ debate — suggesting that sweeping majorities oppose a few of the abortion and reproductive well being care insurance policies backed by the Trump administration.
“Over 70% of the individuals assist Roe v. Wade. Over 90% of the individuals assist funding for Planned Parenthood and ensuring girls can get the well being care they want,” Klobuchar stated.
Those are giant numbers for one of many nation’s most polarizing points. So we determined to have a look and located that Klobuchar was appropriate in summarizing public opinion on Roe v. Wade however overstated assist for Planned Parenthood funding.
Roe v. Wade
Klobuchar’s declare that 70% of Americans assist Roe v. Wade holds up.
An NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll in June discovered that 77% of respondents needed Roe v. Wade upheld — although, inside that group, some individuals supported increasing circumstances wherein abortion is authorized, and others would really like extra restrictions. (The landmark courtroom ruling is the premise for a girls’s proper to an abortion.)
[khn_slabs slabs=”790331″ view=”inline”]
Another ballot, performed in 2018, discovered an analogous determine: 71% of respondents advised NBC/Wall Street Journal pollsters that they opposed overturning the authorized customary.
Funding Planned Parenthood
We couldn’t discover particular polling proof for Klobuchar’s 90% statistic of assist for Planned Parenthood. In truth, we discovered proof indicating assist is decrease.
A majority of Americans do need the federal government to fund the community of clinics that present not solely abortions, but additionally many different well being care companies to primarily low-income girls. The assist takes two kinds: Planned Parenthood can invoice authorities well being plans for non-abortion companies — since federal regulation blocks taxpayer from paying immediately for abortions — and Planned Parenthood clinics are additionally eligible for funding from the federal Title X program, which helps low-income girls’s entry to contraception.
Right now, Planned Parenthood shouldn’t be accepting Title X funding as a result of the Trump administration has banned this system’s grantees from referring patients for abortions.
Polling in April by the Kaiser Family Foundation discovered that 73% of the general public imagine “the government should continue paying Planned Parenthood for non-abortion services provided to people on Medicaid.” (Kaiser Health News is an editorially unbiased program of the inspiration.)
A January 2017 ballot by Quinnipiac discovered a decrease determine: 62% opposed reducing off authorities funding to Planned Parenthood. When respondents discovered that these didn’t fund abortion, assist rose to 80%.
[khn_slabs slabs=”1023558″ view=”pull-right” /]
Klobuchar’s marketing campaign highlighted polling by the progressive polling group PerryUndem. The ballot does reference opposition of 90% to one thing associated to defunding Planned Parenthood, but it surely doesn’t jibe with Klobuchar’s assertion.
The query refers to adults who opposed an agenda that “includes defunding Planned Parenthood” but additionally consists of steps similar to nominating Supreme Court justices who expressly oppose abortion. Even PerryUndem discovered that, on the particular difficulty of defunding Planned Parenthood, 70% of respondents expressed opposition.
Those are important numbers for what has lengthy been a lightning rod of the tradition wars. But they don’t match the statistic Klobuchar cited.
Our Ruling
Klobuchar cited two statistics on the debate: More than 70% of Americans assist Roe v. Wade, and greater than 90% assist funding Planned Parenthood.
Both concepts seem to have majority assist. But we couldn’t discover compelling proof for the 90% determine — polls centered on this explicit difficulty counsel assist is considerably decrease.
With one in all these statistics appropriate and the opposite based mostly on a special, broader polling query, we fee this declare Half True.
This story might be republished at no cost (details). Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar trotted out statistics on the November Democratic presidential candidates’ debate — suggesting that sweeping majorities oppose a few of the abortion and reproductive well being care insurance policies backed by the Trump administration.
“Over 70% of the individuals assist Roe v. Wade. Over 90% of the individuals assist funding for Planned Parenthood and ensuring girls can get the well being care they want,” Klobuchar stated.
Those are giant numbers for one of many nation’s most polarizing points. So we determined to have a look and located that Klobuchar was appropriate in summarizing public opinion on Roe v. Wade however overstated assist for Planned Parenthood funding.
Roe v. Wade
Klobuchar’s declare that 70% of Americans assist Roe v. Wade holds up.
An NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll in June discovered that 77% of respondents needed Roe v. Wade upheld — although, inside that group, some individuals supported increasing circumstances wherein abortion is authorized, and others would really like extra restrictions. (The landmark courtroom ruling is the premise for a girls’s proper to an abortion.)
Another ballot, performed in 2018, discovered an analogous determine: 71% of respondents advised NBC/Wall Street Journal pollsters that they opposed overturning the authorized customary.
Funding Planned Parenthood
We couldn’t discover particular polling proof for Klobuchar’s 90% statistic of assist for Planned Parenthood. In truth, we discovered proof indicating assist is decrease.
A majority of Americans do need the federal government to fund the community of clinics that present not solely abortions, but additionally many different well being care companies to primarily low-income girls. The assist takes two kinds: Planned Parenthood can invoice authorities well being plans for non-abortion companies — since federal regulation blocks taxpayer from paying immediately for abortions — and Planned Parenthood clinics are additionally eligible for funding from the federal Title X program, which helps low-income girls’s entry to contraception.
Right now, Planned Parenthood shouldn’t be accepting Title X funding as a result of the Trump administration has banned this system’s grantees from referring patients for abortions.
Polling in April by the Kaiser Family Foundation discovered that 73% of the general public imagine “the government should continue paying Planned Parenthood for non-abortion services provided to people on Medicaid.” (Kaiser Health News is an editorially unbiased program of the inspiration.)
A January 2017 ballot by Quinnipiac discovered a decrease determine: 62% opposed reducing off authorities funding to Planned Parenthood. When respondents discovered that these didn’t fund abortion, assist rose to 80%.
Klobuchar’s marketing campaign highlighted polling by the progressive polling group PerryUndem. The ballot does reference opposition of 90% to one thing associated to defunding Planned Parenthood, but it surely doesn’t jibe with Klobuchar’s assertion.
The query refers to adults who opposed an agenda that “includes defunding Planned Parenthood” but additionally consists of steps similar to nominating Supreme Court justices who expressly oppose abortion. Even PerryUndem discovered that, on the particular difficulty of defunding Planned Parenthood, 70% of respondents expressed opposition.
Those are important numbers for what has lengthy been a lightning rod of the tradition wars. But they don’t match the statistic Klobuchar cited.
Our Ruling
Klobuchar cited two statistics on the debate: More than 70% of Americans assist Roe v. Wade, and greater than 90% assist funding Planned Parenthood.
Both concepts seem to have majority assist. But we couldn’t discover compelling proof for the 90% determine — polls centered on this explicit difficulty counsel assist is considerably decrease.
With one in all these statistics appropriate and the opposite based mostly on a special, broader polling query, we fee this declare Half True.
