This story additionally ran on NPR. This story will be republished at no cost (details).
From late March into April, Timothy Regan had extreme coughing matches a number of instances a day that always left him out of breath. He had a periodic low-grade fever, too.
Do you could have an exorbitant or baffling medical invoice? Join the KHN and NPR ‘Bill of the Month’ Club and inform us about your expertise. We’ll function a brand new one every month.
Wondering if he had COVID-19, Regan known as a nurse hotline run by Denver Health, a big public well being system in his metropolis. A nurse listened to him describe his signs and advised him to instantly go to the hospital system’s pressing care facility.
When he arrived at Denver Health — the place the emergency room and pressing care facility sit facet by facet at its principal location downtown — a nurse directed him to the ER after he famous chest ache as certainly one of his signs.
Regan was seen rapidly and given a chest X-ray and electrocardiogram, referred to as an EKG, to test his lungs and coronary heart. Both had been regular. A physician prescribed an inhaler to assist his respiration and advised him he might need bronchitis. The physician suggested that he needed to presume he had COVID-19 and should quarantine at dwelling for 2 weeks. At the time, on April three, Denver Health reserved COVID exams for sicker sufferers. Two hours after arriving on the hospital, Regan was again dwelling. His longest wait was for his inhaler prescription to be crammed.
Regan wasn’t involved nearly his personal well being. His spouse, Elissa, who’s anticipating their second baby in August, and their 1-year-old son, Finn, additionally felt sick with COVID-like signs in April. “Nothing terrible, but enough to make me worry,” he stated.
When Timothy had coughing matches and a low-grade fever from late March into April, his COVID-19 worries weren’t solely about himself. He was additionally involved for his pregnant spouse, Elissa, and their 1-year-old, Finn, each of whom additionally felt sick with COVID signs in April.(Ethan Welty for KHN)
Regan, who’s an estimator for a development agency, labored all through his illness — together with whereas quarantined at dwelling. (Construction in Colorado and lots of states has been thought of a necessary enterprise and has continued to function.) Regan stated he was frightened about taking a break day and shedding his job.
“I was thinking I had to make all the money I could in case we all had to be hospitalized,” he stated. “All I could do was keep working in hopes that everything would be OK.”
Within a few weeks, the entire household, certainly, was OK. “We got lucky,” Elissa stated.
Then the invoice got here.
The Patient: Timothy Regan, 40, an estimator for a development firm. The household has medical health insurance by Elissa’s job at a nonprofit in Denver.
Total Bill: Denver Health billed Regan $three,278 for the ER go to. His insurer paid $1,042, leaving Regan with $2,236 to pay based mostly on his $three,500 in-network deductible. The greatest a part of the invoice was the $2,921 common ER charge.
Service Provider: Denver Health, a big public well being system
Medical Service: Regan was evaluated within the emergency room for COVID-like signs, together with a extreme cough, fever and chest ache. He was given a number of exams to test his coronary heart and lungs, prescribed an inhaler and despatched dwelling.
Email Sign-Up
Subscribe to KHN’s free Morning Briefing.
What Gives: When sufferers use hospital emergency rooms — even for brief visits with few exams — it’s commonplace for them to get billed 1000’s of irrespective of how minor the remedy acquired. Hospitals say the excessive charges come from having to workers the ER with specialists 24 hours a day and maintain lifesaving tools updated.
Denver Health coded Timothy’s ER go to as a Level four — the second-highest and second-most costly — on a 5-point scale. The different objects on his invoice had been $225 for the EKG, $126 for the chest X-ray and $6 for his albuterol inhaler, a medicine that gives fast aid for respiration issues.
The Regans knew that they had a excessive deductible they usually attempt to keep away from unnecessarily utilizing the ER. But, with doctor places of work not seeing sufferers with COVID-type signs in April, Timothy stated he had little alternative when Denver Health directed him first to the pressing care, then to its ER. “I felt bad, but I had been dealing with it for a while,” he stated.
Elissa stated they had been attempting laborious to do all the things by the ebook, together with utilizing a well being supplier of their plan’s community.
“We did not anticipate being hit with such a huge bill for the visit,” Elissa stated. “We had intentionally called the nurse’s line trying to be responsible, but that did not work.”
In an effort to take away limitations from folks getting examined and evaluated for COVID-19, UnitedHealthcare is certainly one of many insurers that introduced it’ll waive cost sharing for COVID-19 testing-related visits and remedy. But it’s not clear how many individuals who had COVID signs however didn’t get examined when exams had been briefly provide have been billed because the Regans had been.
Timothy and Elissa attempt to keep away from needlessly visiting the ER due to their high-deductible insurance coverage plan, they are saying. Denver Health billed $three,278 for Timothy’s ER go to, leaving the Regans with a $2,236 tab based mostly on their $three,500 in-network deductible. UnitedHealthcare officers reviewed his case on the request of KHN, and waived the couple’s price sharing for the go to.(Ethan Welty for KHN)
Resolution: A Denver Health spokesperson stated Regan was not examined for COVID as a result of he was not admitted and didn’t have threat components similar to diabetes, coronary heart illness or bronchial asthma. He was not billed as a COVID affected person as a result of he was not examined for the virus. The medical heart has since expanded its testing capability, the spokesperson stated.
UnitedHealthcare officers reviewed Regan’s case on the request of KHN. Based on Regan’s signs and the exams carried out, Denver Health ought to have billed them utilizing a COVID billing code, an insurer spokesperson stated. “We reprocessed Mr. Regan’s original claims after reviewing the services that he received,” a United Healthcare spokesperson stated. “All cost share for that visit has been waived.”
The Regans stated they had been thrilled with UHC’s choice.
“That is wonderful news,” Elissa Regan stated upon listening to from a KHN reporter that UHC would waive their prices. “We are very thankful. It is a huge relief.”
Timothy, Elissa and Finn all skilled COVID signs. Though they tried to do all the things by the ebook, a visit to the ER for Timothy resulted in a $2,236 tab for the Regans, earlier than their well being insurer, UnitedHealthcare, subsequently waived it.(Ethan Welty for KHN)
The Takeaway: The Regans stated they initially discovered no satisfaction in calling the hospital or the insurer to resolve their dispute ― however it was the best factor to do.
“He’s definitely not alone,” stated Sabrina Corlette, a analysis professor at Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms. “The takeaway here is both the provider as well as insurance company are still on a learning curve with respect to this virus and how to bill and pay for it.”
Corlette stated Timothy shouldn’t have second-guessed his choice to make use of the Denver Health ER when directed there by a nurse. That, too, was the best name.
Insurers’ strikes to waive prices related to COVID testing and associated remedy is important to stemming the outbreak — however it works provided that sufferers can belief they received’t get caught with a big invoice, she stated. “It’s a critical piece of the public health strategy to beat this disease,” Corlette stated.
To assist with billing, she stated, sufferers may ask their supplier to notice on their medical chart when they’re looking for take care of attainable COVID-19. But it’s not the affected person’s duty to verify suppliers use the best billing code, she stated. Patients have to know they’ve the best to attraction prices to their insurer. They can even search help from their employer’s advantages division and state insurance coverage division.
Bill of the Month is a crowdsourced investigation by Kaiser Health News and NPR that dissects and explains medical payments. Do you could have an fascinating medical invoice you wish to share with us? Tell us about it!
Phil Galewitz: [email protected]”>[email protected], @philgalewitz
Related Topics Health Care Costs Health Industry Insurance Multimedia Public Health States Bill Of The Month Colorado COVID-19 Emergency Medicine Hospitals Insurers src=”http://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js” charset=”utf-Eight”>
