Stephanie Armour
Dining below palm bushes on a patio at Mar-a-Lago in December, President-elect Donald Trump reassured chief executives at pharmaceutical giants Eli Lilly and Pfizer that anti-vaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. wouldn’t be a radical selection to move the Department of Health and Human Services.
“I think he’s going to be much less radical than you would think,” Trump stated later that month throughout a news conference at his Palm Beach, Florida, resort.
Eight months have handed, and Kennedy is intensifying his assaults on the vaccine system.
High on his listing of targets: a federal vaccine compensation program that settles harm claims. His technique might bankrupt or diminish the fund, some authorized students and public well being leaders say, saddling pharmaceutical firms with legal responsibility dangers and prices that might compel them to cease making vaccines altogether.
“It’s a radical agenda,” stated Angela Rasmussen, a virologist on the Vaccine and Infectious Disease Organization on the University of Saskatchewan in Canada. “He’s using a bunch of different mechanisms and there really are no guardrails. People are going to catch on but it’s not going to be enough to stop the waves of deaths, and deaths of children.”
Kennedy has stated modifications to the U.S. vaccine system are wanted as a result of, he asserts with out proof, immunizations are linked to autism, neurotoxicity, allergy symptoms, and demise. He is a frontrunner of the “Make America Healthy Again” motion, an off-the-cuff marketing campaign that eschews conventional drugs and espouses “medical freedom.” Many adherents oppose vaccines and consider they’re unsafe regardless of scientific proof on the contrary.
Kennedy has acknowledged he desires to reform the vaccine fund, often known as the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, writing July 28 on the social platform X that “the VICP is broken, and I intend to fix it.” HHS is working with the Department of Justice to revamp the program, which shields drugmakers from most legal responsibility over accidents.
HHS didn’t reply to a request to talk with Kennedy, however company officers stated he isn’t against immunizations.
“Secretary Kennedy is not anti-vaccine — he is pro-safety, pro-transparency, and pro-accountability,” HHS spokesperson Vianca Rodriguez Feliciano stated in an electronic mail.
Yet behind the scenes, Kennedy has been laying the groundwork to limit the supply of broadly used immunizations, in response to individuals aware of inside discussions who requested to not be recognized as a result of they’re not licensed to talk on the subject.
A Multipronged Strategy
The technique started taking form within the spring. The first step: Raise unfounded questions in regards to the security of vaccines. At a Cabinet assembly in April, Kennedy advised Trump that HHS was enterprise a large examine that might establish the reason for rising autism diagnoses by September.
Kennedy tasked David Geier, a researcher who’s repeated the debunked declare that vaccines trigger autism, to supervise the work, in response to media reports.
Kennedy then doubled down by questioning the use of aluminum, which is added to many vaccines to assist enhance the immune response. He linked it to allergy symptoms at a July assembly of governors, although a recent study within the Annals of Internal Medicine discovered no connection. He’s broadly anticipated to ask a federal vaccine advisory committee to conduct a review.
The autism analysis and considerations about aluminum have been early salvos within the push to go after the compensation fund, in response to two of the individuals.
That fund offers cash to individuals for accidents from vaccines and has paid out greater than $5 billion because it was established in 1988, in response to the Health Resources and Services Administration.
Before submitting a lawsuit in court docket, injured people deliver their claims to this system’s nonjury vaccine court docket, which opinions proof. The fund offers compensation from a small excise tax on vaccines.
Compensation is decided partially by a desk maintained by HRSA and overseen by the HHS secretary. It lists every vaccine and related accidents and encompasses routine vaccinations really useful by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention which can be topic to the excise tax. The accidents embody anaphylaxis and encephalitis. People who expertise such accidents inside a sure time after getting a selected vaccine can get cash.
Kennedy desires to get autism or allergy symptoms added to that doc, in response to two individuals aware of inside discussions and concerns raised publicly by some vaccine builders and former regulators. He might accomplish the purpose if HHS-led analysis blames vaccines for autism, for instance, or if a federal vaccine advisory panel recommends towards aluminum in vaccines, in response to some authorized students.
“Given the rate of autism, if a lot of cases are brought, that could bankrupt the program,” stated Dorit Reiss, a professor at University of California Law San Francisco.
If that have been to occur, pharmaceutical firms might cease producing the immunizations, which don’t are usually very worthwhile, quite than get entangled in drawn-out, costly lawsuits from claimants who can’t get cash as a result of the federal vaccine harm fund has run dry, some authorized specialists and vaccine builders stated.
“The compensation fund, if it’s gone, would impact decisions to proceed or not to proceed,” stated David Dodd, president and CEO of GeoVax Labs, a biotechnology firm creating vaccines and immunotherapies.
A federal vaccine advisory panel might additionally suggest towards aluminum in pictures, forcing drugmakers to make expensive reformulations or exit the market.
Kennedy has positioned individuals round him to execute the technique. He’s pushed to get vaccine skeptics in decision-making positions on the CDC, which recommends vaccines, and the Food and Drug Administration, which approves them.
He additionally tapped leaders within the anti-vaccine motion to vet candidates for him.
The consequence has been regulatory and coverage choices which have winnowed vaccine entry and growth.
HHS this month stated it was halting $500 million in grants and contracts for the event of mRNA vaccines, together with an improved, extra sturdy covid mRNA vaccine.
The federal authorities stopped recommending covid shots for wholesome pregnant ladies and kids, bypassing enter from a vaccine advisory committee that historically would have weighed in.
And Kennedy reconstituted that committee together with his personal handpicked members, together with vaccine skeptics, and eliminated the American Medical Association, American Nurses Association, and different trade teams that served as committee liaisons. The modified panel really useful towards flu vaccines containing a preservative erroneously linked to autism.
The White House Calls
Kennedy’s willpower to maintain vaccine skeptics in oversight positions performed out in a deal he lately made with Trump and his employees, in response to two individuals aware of the state of affairs. The association got here collectively on a Sunday night time in July when Kennedy bought a name from the White House.
The topic was Vinay Prasad, a prime vaccine regulator on the FDA. He had lately touched off a wave of industry criticism for enjoying a job within the company’s choice to ask biotech firm Sarepta Therapeutics to halt shipments of a gene remedy over security considerations.
Social media posts and conservative commentators whipped up a furor. Laura Loomer, a far-right provocateur, stated July 21 on X that Prasad must be fired and known as him “a self-proclaimed progressive liberal and Bernie Sanders fanboy,” referring to Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.). Congressional lawmakers started peppering the White House with questions.
The furor reached Trump, who wanted Prasad out, in response to the individuals. But Kennedy was involved about dropping Prasad. He felt he wanted a critic of immunizations overseeing vaccines on the company.
So Kennedy struck a deal. Prasad can be requested to resign as head of the FDA’s Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research, which regulates vaccine merchandise and biologics corresponding to gene therapies. And the middle can be divided into two operations, with Kennedy empowered to pick out the individual overseeing vaccines.
Some public well being leaders publicly shared particulars of the association and raised considerations about its potential impression. Former FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb stated in an Aug. 1 interview on CNBC that he thought it “would be very destructive to the agency.”
After leaving the company in July, Prasad is now returning, although it’s unclear if his position has modified.
Recently, Kennedy was sued by Ray Flores, senior outside counsel for Children’s Health Defense. An anti-vaccine group based by Kennedy, Children’s Health Defense is funding the swimsuit, which claims Kennedy failed to launch a process pressure to review vaccine security that it says is required to report findings to Congress. But Kennedy and his allies view the lawsuit as pleasant, in response to one individual aware of the matter, as a result of it’s in search of an consequence that he desires.
HHS on Aug. 14 introduced it was reviving a federal panel, disbanded in 1998, to supply oversight of pediatric vaccines.
Kennedy’s work towards vaccines has triggered unfriendly lawsuits too, together with one introduced by the American Academy of Pediatrics and different public well being teams. His latest choice to halt funds for mRNA vaccine growth yielded a swell of social media criticism.
“This is reckless. This is dangerous. This will cost lives. We must fight back,” Sen. Edward Markey (D-Mass.) stated Aug. 5 on X.
“I’ve tried to be objective & non-alarmist in response to current HHS actions – but quite frankly this move is going to cost lives,” Jerome Adams, who was U.S. surgeon basic in the course of the earlier Trump administration, stated Aug. 5 on the identical platform.
Kennedy and his backers stay undeterred. In a counterpunch, his supporters are launching an unprecedented public relations marketing campaign to advertise the HHS secretary, spurring hypothesis that he could also be mulling a 2028 presidential run.
The nonprofit MAHA Action held a call in July to energise Kennedy supporters and initiated a six-figure ad campaign extolling Kennedy and Trump administration well being initiatives.
“Make no mistake, this is a revolution that will change the face of public health policy,” Tony Lyons, president of MAHA Action, stated in an announcement. “Americans are demanding radical transparency and gold standard science.”
KFF Health News is a nationwide newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about well being points and is without doubt one of the core working packages at KFF—an unbiased supply of well being coverage analysis, polling, and journalism. Learn extra about KFF.
USE OUR CONTENT
This story could be republished without cost (details).
