Cara Anthony
For essentially the most half, Keyanna Jones and her husband thought they knew what to anticipate when their daughter Chloë had eye surgical procedure final fall.
Even Chloë, who was in kindergarten, had understanding of how issues would go that day. Before the process, a hospital employee gave her a coloring ebook that defined the steps of the surgical procedure — a process to appropriate a situation that might have finally interfered along with her imaginative and prescient.
“Chloë is very smart,” Jones mentioned. “She reads at almost a third-grade level now, and she’s only 6.”
Jones did her homework, too. With no pediatric ophthalmologists close to their house in Wentzville, Missouri, who would take their insurance coverage, she requested the insurer to cowl Chloë’s out-of-network care as if it have been in-network. The insurer agreed to let her see an out-of-network specialist.
Chloë made it by surgical procedure with out a hitch. Jones mentioned her daughter loved a number of popsicles on the hospital earlier than going house.
“ I slept with her every night because she was so worried she would wake up and not be able to see,” she mentioned. “But it healed beautifully, and she was absolutely ready to go back to school.”
Then the invoice got here.
The Medical Procedure
Chloë was born with a droopy left eyelid, a situation often called ptosis. To appropriate the issue, an ophthalmologist surgically lifts the eyelid, stopping it from disrupting the affected person’s line of sight.
Ophthalmologists, not like optometrists and opticians, maintain medical levels and might present superior eye care, together with surgical procedure.
The Final Bill
$15,188, together with $10,382 for the process and $2,730 for anesthesia. Initially, insurance coverage paid simply $1,775.79, leaving the Jones household owing $13,412.21 — till Chloë’s uncle, who had just lately completed his time period as a state senator, requested a colleague to look into it.
The Problem: Phantom Insurance Approval?
Months earlier than Chloë inhaled bubblegum-scented anesthetic at Cardinal Glennon Children’s Hospital in St. Louis, Jones found that it may be arduous to discover a pediatric ophthalmologist. The physician beneficial by Chloë’s pediatrician wasn’t contracted with their insurer, UnitedHealthcare, and the closest in-network specialist was in Wisconsin, a whole lot of miles away.
So Jones requested what’s referred to as a community hole exception, beneath which the insurer would cowl the beneficial physician’s providers as in-network.
Before the surgical procedure was scheduled, she acquired a letter saying UnitedHealthcare had accredited her request “because currently there isn’t a doctor, health care professional, or facility in your area to provide these services.” The letter listed a number of medical billing codes for eye providers and mentioned they’d be lined “at the network level.”
About per week later, the insurer despatched a previous authorization letter approving Chloë’s surgical procedure.
But UnitedHealthcare declined to pay many of the surgical procedure invoice, overlaying it as out-of-network. With approval letters in hand, Jones mentioned, she didn’t perceive why the insurer apparently was not honoring its settlement to cowl her daughter’s remedy.
In truth, the similar-looking letters granted totally different sorts of approval.
UnitedHealthcare’s hole exception accredited Chloë’s exams earlier than the surgical procedure as in-network. But in its prior authorization letter for her surgical procedure with the identical physician, the insurer mentioned solely that it will cowl it — with out providing community reductions.
After receiving the invoice, Jones contacted the insurer on-line, however she mentioned a consultant advised her there was no file of its approval to cowl the surgical procedure as in-network.
“At that point, I didn’t even know what to do,” she mentioned. “I’m like, ‘This is crazy.’”
She mentioned she despatched over a duplicate of one of many approval letters, which was on the corporate’s letterhead, however a consultant advised her the letter hadn’t come from UnitedHealthcare.
“They said, ‘You saw this surgeon, they’re not covered and you didn’t have permission, so, no, we’re not going to pay,’” Jones mentioned, recounting the telephone name.
An insurance coverage consultant advised Jones she owed greater than $13,000 due to “a balance billing issue.” That meant the Jones household must pay the $13,000-plus stability.
Spokespeople for UnitedHealthcare confirmed the corporate supplied a niche exception and prior authorization for Chloë’s care. Eric Hausman, a spokesperson for UnitedHealth Group, mentioned in a press release to KFF Health News that “we empathize with anyone who finds themselves in the unfortunate situation of being balance billed by an out-of-network provider for an amount significantly above market rates, and without any advance knowledge.”
Maryanne Wallace, a spokesperson for SSM Health, the well being system that features Cardinal Glennon Children’s Hospital, supplied a press release that mentioned SSM adopted “standard patient billing procedures.”
“Occasionally, an insurance company may process a claim as an out-of-network service, which can result in a balance being billed to the patient,” the assertion mentioned.
The Resolution
Jones mentioned she was blindsided by the massive invoice. She tried to repair the issue on her personal, she mentioned, conserving observe of each interplay with the insurer and the hospital. She filed appeals with UnitedHealthcare.
Nothing helped — till she reached out to her brother Caleb Rowden, who had been a Missouri state senator for eight years after serving 4 years within the state House.
“ I’ve never used my brother’s political clout for anything,” she mentioned. “I actually hate politics.”
Rowden advised KFF Health News that he reached out to Travis Fitzwater, the state senator representing his niece’s district. Jones contacted Fitzwater’s workplace, too, and despatched a grievance to Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey.
Fitzwater mentioned his workplace did no extra for Chloë than it will for any constituent.
“We’re not going to take a lot of credit for the result of it, because we didn’t ask for anything other than a resolution, so that everybody can be at peace and move on with their lives,” he mentioned in an interview. “We just did what we do every day.”
After Fitzwater’s employees contacted the hospital and the insurer, representatives from each individually referred to as Jones and notified her that UnitedHealthcare had paid the invoice in full.
In the top, Chloë’s household paid nothing for her process — not even a copay.
The Takeaway
When it involves insurance coverage approvals, learn the advantageous print rigorously; “covered” doesn’t imply an insurer pays, not to mention at in-network charges.
Rowden and Fitzwater mentioned reaching out to your elected consultant’s workplace may help. Advocating for constituents is a part of their job.
“They usually have an open line of communication with these insurance companies and hospitals,” Rowden wrote in an e mail. “They may not always be able to get to a positive outcome since every situation is a little different, but they can usually get you to a next step.”
Jones is grateful that her brother was capable of assist, although she acknowledged that she most likely wouldn’t have referred to as him with out a nudge from their mom. “I think I would still be fighting,” she mentioned.
Bill of the Month is a crowdsourced investigation by KFF Health News and The Washington Post’s Well+Being that dissects and explains medical payments. Since 2018, this collection has helped many sufferers and readers get their medical payments diminished, and it has been cited in statehouses, on the U.S. Capitol, and on the White House. Do you’ve a complicated or outrageous medical invoice you need to share? Tell us about it!
KFF Health News is a nationwide newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about well being points and is likely one of the core working packages at KFF—an unbiased supply of well being coverage analysis, polling, and journalism. Learn extra about KFF.
USE OUR CONTENT
This story could be republished free of charge (details).
