This story additionally ran on NPR. This story will be republished without spending a dime (details).
At 87, Maxine Stanich cared extra about bettering the standard of her life than prolonging it.
She suffered from a protracted checklist of well being issues, together with coronary heart failure and continual lung illness that might go away her gasping for breath.
When her time got here, she needed to die a pure dying, Stanich informed her daughter, and signed a “do not resuscitate” directive, or DNR, ordering medical doctors to not revive her ought to her coronary heart cease.
In this collection, “Treatment Overkill,” Kaiser Health News investigates the causes and penalties of medical overtreatment, each for sufferers and the well being care system.
Yet a visit to a San Francisco emergency room for shortness of breath in 2008 led Stanich to get a defibrillator implanted in her chest — a medical machine to maintain her alive by delivering a strong shock. At the time, Stanich didn’t absolutely grasp what she had agreed to, though she signed a doc granting permission for the process, stated her daughter, Susan Giaquinto.
Stanich, at age 87, had signed a “do not resuscitate” directive, ordering medical doctors to not revive her ought to her coronary heart cease, however medical doctors gave her a defibrillator anyway. (Photo courtesy of Susan Giaquinto)
That readability got here solely throughout a subsequent go to to a distinct hospital, when a shocked ER physician noticed a defibrillator protruding from the DNR affected person’s skinny chest. To Stanich’s horror, the ER physician defined that the machine wouldn’t permit her to slide away painlessly and that the jolt can be “so strong that it will knock her across the room,” stated Giaquinto, who accompanied her mom on each hospital journeys.
Surgery like this has turn out to be all too widespread amongst these close to the top of life, consultants say. Nearly 1 in 3 Medicare patients bear an operation within the yr earlier than they die, though the proof exhibits that many usually tend to be harmed than to learn from it.
The observe is pushed by monetary incentives that reward medical doctors for doing procedures, in addition to a medical tradition wherein sufferers and medical doctors are reluctant to speak about how surgical interventions must be prescribed extra judiciously, stated Dr. Rita Redberg, a heart specialist who handled Stanich when she sought care on the second hospital.
“We have a culture that believes in very aggressive care,” stated Redberg, who on the University of California-San Francisco focuses on coronary heart illness in girls. “We are often not considering the chance of benefit and chance of harm, and how that changes when you get older. We also fail to have conversations about what patients value most.”
While surgical procedure is usually lifesaving for youthful folks, working on frail, older sufferers not often helps them stay longer or returns the standard of life they as soon as loved, in accordance with a 2016 paper in Annals of Surgery.
The value of those surgical procedures — sometimes paid for by Medicare, the federal government medical health insurance program for folks over 65 — contain greater than cash, stated Dr. Amber Barnato, a professor on the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice. Older sufferers who bear surgical procedure inside a yr of dying spent 50 p.c extra time within the hospital than others, and almost twice as many days in intensive care.
And whereas some sturdy octogenarians have a few years forward of them, research present that surgical procedure can be widespread amongst those that are way more frail.
Don’t Miss A Story
Subscribe to KHN’s free Weekly Edition e-newsletter.
Eighteen p.c of Medicare sufferers have surgical procedure of their remaining month of life and eight p.c of their remaining week, in accordance with a 2011 study in The Lancet.
More than 12 p.c of defibrillators have been implanted in folks older than 80, according to a 2015 study. Doctors implant about 158,000 of the units every year, in accordance with the American College of Cardiology. The whole cost of the process runs about $60,000.
Procedures carried out within the aged vary from main operations that require prolonged recoveries to comparatively minor surgical procedure carried out in a health care provider’s workplace, such because the elimination of nonfatal pores and skin cancers, that might probably by no means trigger any issues.
Research led by Dr. Eleni Linos has proven that folks with restricted life expectations are handled for nonfatal pores and skin cancers as aggressively as youthful sufferers. Among sufferers with a nonfatal pores and skin most cancers and a restricted time to stay, 70 p.c underwent surgical procedure, in accordance with her 2013 study in JAMA Internal Medicine.
When Less Is More
Maxine Stanich celebrated her 90th birthday with family and friends in 2010 greater than two years after Dr. Rita Redberg had deactivated a defibrillator and discharged her with dwelling hospice service. Stanich, at age 87, had signed a “do not resuscitate” directive, ordering medical doctors to not revive her ought to her coronary heart cease, however medical doctors gave her a defibrillator anyway. (Photo courtesy of Susan Giaquinto)
Surgery poses severe dangers for older folks, who climate anesthesia poorly and whose pores and skin takes longer to heal. Among seniors who bear pressing or emergency belly surgical procedure, 20 p.c die inside 30 days, studies show.
With diminished psychological acuity and an old style respect for the medical career, some ageing sufferers are susceptible to undesirable interventions. Stanich agreed to a pacemaker just because her physician recommended it, Giaquinto stated. Many folks of Stanich’s technology “thought doctors were God … They never questioned doctors — ever.”
Dr. Margaret Schwarze, a surgeon and affiliate professor on the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, stated that older sufferers typically don’t really feel the monetary ache of surgical procedure as a result of insurance coverage pays many of the value.
When a surgeon gives to “fix” the center valve in an individual with a number of illnesses, for instance, the affected person might assume that surgical procedure will fix all of her medical problems, Schwarze stated. “With older patients with lots of chronic illnesses, we’re not really fixing anything.”
Even as a health care provider, Redberg stated, she struggles to stop different medical doctors from performing too many procedures on her 92-year-old mom, Mae, who lives in New York City.
Redberg stated medical doctors just lately handled her mom for melanoma — essentially the most severe kind of pores and skin most cancers. After the most cancers was faraway from her leg, Redberg’s mom was urged by a health care provider to bear an extra surgical procedure to chop away extra tissue and close by lymph nodes, which might harbor cancerous cells.
“Every time she went in, the dermatologist wanted to refer her to a surgeon,” Redberg stated. And “Medicare would have been happy to pay for it.”
But her mom typically has issues with wounds therapeutic, she stated, and restoration would probably have taken three months. When Redberg pressed a surgeon about the advantages, he stated the process may scale back the probabilities of most cancers coming again inside three to 5 years.
Redberg stated her mom laughed and stated, “I’m not interested in doing something that will help me in three to five years. I doubt I’ll be here.”
Dr. Rita Redberg, director of girls’s cardiovascular providers on the University of California-San Francisco Division of Cardiology, tends to her mom, Mae Redberg, in Mae’s condominium in Manhattan. (Yana Paskova for Kaiser Health News)
Mae Redberg rests in her condominium in Manhattan. (Photo by Yana Paskova for Kaiser Health News)
Finding Solutions
The momentum of hospital care could make folks really feel as in the event that they’re on a transferring prepare and might’t soar off.
The rush of medical selections “doesn’t allow time to deliberate or consider the patients’ overall health or what their goals and values might be,” stated Dr. Jacqueline Kruser, an teacher in pulmonary and significant care drugs and medical social sciences on the Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine.
Many hospitals and well being programs are creating “decision aids,” easy-to-understand written materials and videos to assist sufferers make extra knowledgeable medical selections, giving them time to develop extra lifelike expectations.
After Kaiser Permanente Washington launched the instruments referring to joint substitute, the variety of sufferers selecting to have hip substitute surgical procedure fell 26 p.c, whereas knee replacements declined 38 p.c, in accordance with a research in Health Affairs. (Kaiser Permanente will not be affiliated with Kaiser Health News, which is an editorially impartial program of the Kaiser Family Foundation.)
In a paper published last year in JAMA Surgery and the Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, Schwarze, Kruser and colleagues recommended creating narratives as an example surgical dangers, relatively than counting on statistics.
Instead of telling sufferers that surgical procedure carries a 20 p.c threat of stroke, for instance, medical doctors ought to lay out one of the best, worst and most definitely outcomes.
We have a tradition that believes in very aggressive care. We are sometimes not contemplating the prospect of profit and likelihood of hurt, and the way that adjustments while you become older. We additionally fail to have conversations about what sufferers worth most.
Dr. Rita Redberg, director of girls’s cardiovascular providers on the University of California-San Francisco Division of Cardiology
In the best-case situation, a affected person would possibly spend weeks within the hospital after surgical procedure, dwelling the remainder of her life in a nursing dwelling. In the worst case, the identical affected person dies after a number of weeks in intensive care. In the most definitely situation, the affected person survives simply two to a few months after surgical procedure.
Schwarze stated, “If someone says they can’t tolerate the best-case scenario — which involves them being in a nursing home — then maybe we shouldn’t be doing this.”
Maxine Stanich was admitted to the hospital after going to the ER as a result of she felt wanting breath. She skilled an irregular coronary heart rhythm within the process room throughout a cardiac check —not an uncommon occasion throughout a process wherein a wire is threaded into the center. Based on that, medical doctors determined to implant a pacemaker and defibrillator the following day.
Dr. Redberg was consulted when the affected person objected to the machine that was now embedded in her chest. She was “very alert. She was very clear about what she did and did not want done. She told me she didn’t want to be shocked,” Redberg stated.
After Redberg deactivated the defibrillator, which will be reprogrammed remotely, Stanich was discharged, with dwelling hospice service. With nothing greater than her medicines, she survived one other two years and three months, dying at dwelling simply after her 90th birthday in 2010.
KHN’s protection associated to ageing and bettering care of older adults is supported partially by The John A. Hartford Foundation.
Liz Szabo: [email protected]”>[email protected], @LizSzabo
Related Topics Aging Health Industry Medicare Public Health End Of Life Treatment Overkill src=”http://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js” charset=”utf-Eight”>
