Medicare Vs. Medicare Advantage: How To Choose

As well being insurers battle with shifting authorities insurance policies and appreciable uncertainty, one market stays remarkably secure: Medicare Advantage plans.

That’s excellent news for seniors as they choose protection for the yr forward throughout Medicare’s annual open enrollment interval (this yr operating from Oct. 15 to Dec. 7).

For 2018, 2,317 Medicare Advantage plans will probably be obtainable throughout the nation, “the most we’ve seen since 2009,” mentioned Gretchen Jacobson, affiliate director of the Kaiser Family Foundation’s program on Medicare coverage. (Kaiser Health News is an editorially impartial program of the inspiration.)

Medicare Advantage is an alternative to traditional Medicare. Run by personal insurance coverage firms, the plans — largely well being upkeep organizations (HMOs) and most well-liked supplier organizations (PPOs) — are anticipated to serve a document 20.4 million people subsequent yr, or barely greater than one-third of Medicare’s 59 million members.

On common, seniors will have a choice of 21 plans, although in some counties and enormous metropolitan areas no less than 40 plans will probably be accessible, Jacobson mentioned. Availability tends to be much more restricted in rural areas.

While a number of insurers are getting into or exiting the Medicare Advantage market, most established gamers are remaining in place. Eight insurers dominate the market: UnitedHealthcare, Humana, Anthem, plans affiliated with Blue Cross and Blue Shield, Kaiser Permanente, Aetna, Cigna and WellCare. (Kaiser Health News is unaffiliated with Kaiser Permanente.)


Navigating Aging focuses on medical points and recommendation related to getting old and end-of-life care, serving to America’s 45 million seniors and their households navigate the well being care system.

To contact Judith with a query or remark, click here.

For extra KHN protection of getting old, click here.

Despite Medicare Advantage plans’ rising recognition, a number of options — notably, the prices that older adults face in these plans and the extent to which members’ selection of docs and hospitals is restricted — stay poorly understood.

Here are some important info to contemplate:

The Basics

Medicare Advantage plans should present the identical advantages provided by way of conventional Medicare (providers from hospitals, physicians, house well being care businesses, laboratories, medical gear firms and rehabilitation amenities, amongst others). Nearly 90 % of plans additionally provide drug protection.

In 2018, 68 % of plans provided will probably be HMOs, whereas 27 % will probably be PPOs, Jacobson mentioned. The the rest are small, specialised plans which might be anticipated to have comparatively few members. In basic, HMOs require members to hunt care from a selected community of hospital and docs whereas PPOs enable members to acquire care from suppliers outdoors the community, at a considerably increased value.

Pros And Cons

The Center for Medicare Advocacy not too long ago summarized the professionals and cons of Medicare Advantage plans. On the plus aspect, it cited:

Little paperwork. (Plan members don’t need to submit claims, typically.) An emphasis on preventive care. Extra advantages, resembling imaginative and prescient care, dental care and listening to exams, that aren’t provided below conventional Medicare. An all-in-one method to protection. (Notably, members sometimes don’t need to buy supplemental Medigap protection or a standalone drug plan.) Cost controls, together with a cap on out-of-pocket prices for doctor and hospital providers (Medicare Part A and B advantages).

On the destructive aspect, it cited:

Access is proscribed to hospitals and docs inside plan networks. (Traditional Medicare permits seniors to go to whichever physician or hospital they need.) Techniques to handle medical care that may erect obstacles to accessing care (for instance, getting prior approval from a main care physician earlier than seeing a specialist). Financial incentives to restrict providers. (Medicare Advantage plans obtain a set per-member-per-month price from the federal government and threat shedding cash if medical bills exceed funds.) Limits on care members can get when touring. (Generally, solely emergency care and pressing care is roofed.) The potential for increased prices for particular providers in some circumstances. (Some plans cost greater than conventional Medicare for a brief hospital keep, house well being care or medical gear resembling oxygen, as an illustration.) Lack of flexibility. Once somebody enrolls in Medicare Advantage, they’re locked in for the yr. There are two exceptions: a particular disenrollment interval from Jan. 1 to Feb. 14 (anybody who leaves throughout this time should return to conventional Medicare) and an opportunity to make adjustments throughout open enrollment (shifting to a special plan or going again to conventional Medicare are choices at this level).

Medigap Implications

Choosing a Medicare Advantage plan has implications for the longer term in addition to the current. Notably, if somebody enrolls in a Medicare Advantage plan when she first joins Medicare and stays with a plan for no less than a yr, she could not qualify for supplemental Medigap protection if she needs to affix conventional Medicare at a later date.

Medigap insurance policies cowl expenses resembling deductibles, coinsurance and copayments that seniors with Medicare protection are anticipated to pay out-of-pocket. People who be part of Medicare for the primary time are assured entry to Medigap insurance policies, it doesn’t matter what their well being standing is, just for a restricted time. Afterward, they are often denied protection based mostly on their well being in most states.

Parsing Costs

There’s a widespread notion that Medicare Advantage plans value lower than conventional Medicare. But precise prices rely upon a person’s circumstances and aren’t all the time straightforward to calculate.

Seniors usually first think about what they’ll pay in month-to-month premiums. This yr, the common month-to-month premium for Medicare Advantage plans is $30, nearly $2 beneath final yr’s. But almost half of Medicare members are enrolled in plans that don’t cost a month-to-month premium — so-called zero premium plans. (Seniors additionally must pay Medicare Part B premiums, though some Medicare Advantage plans cowl some or all of that cost.)

To get a full image of plan prices, which might differ yearly, seniors ought to look past premiums to drug bills (together with which medicine are coated by their plan, at what stage and with what restrictions); deductibles (plans can cost deductibles for each medical providers and medicines); what plans cost for hospital care (some have day by day copayments for the primary week or so); and coinsurance charges for providers resembling house well being care or expert nursing care, consultants mentioned.

“It’s really critical that folks dip deep and find out about all possible costs they may incur in a plan before they sign up for it,” mentioned Chris Reeg, director of Ohio’s Senior Health Insurance Information Program. (Every state has a program of this sort; discover one close to you at

“Part of the equation has to be what you’ll have to pay if you need lots of care,” mentioned David Lipschutz, senior coverage legal professional on the Center for Medicare Advocacy “In our experience, that’s often more than people expected.”

Since 2011, Medicare Advantage plans have restricted members’ annual out-of-pocket prices to not more than $6,700 — a type of monetary safety. There is not any comparable restrict in conventional Medicare. Yet, safety isn’t full since out-of-pocket limits don’t apply to drug prices, which will be appreciable. (In PPOs, a cap of $10,000 limits prices for providers obtained from out-of-network suppliers as effectively.)

Plans have discretion in setting out-of-pocket limits. In 2018, 43 % of plans could have out-of-pocket limits exceeding $6,000; 31 % will set limits between $four,000 and $6,000; 20 % could have limits between $three,000 and $four,000; and 6 % will set limits beneath $three,000, based on a brand new Avalere Health evaluation.

Information about Medicare Advantage plans’ deductibles, copayments and coinsurances charges for medical providers in addition to protection particulars for the drugs you’re taking will be discovered at Medicare’s plan finder.

Finding A Doctor

One method that Medicare Advantage plans attempt to management prices and coordinate care is by working with a restricted group of physicians and hospitals. But reliable information about these networks is hard to find and revealed directories usually include mistaken or out-of-date data.

“It’s not easy to determine who’s in-network for a Medicare Advantage plan,” mentioned Fred Riccardi, director of shopper providers on the Medicare Rights Center. “This information isn’t on Medicare’s website and there’s no one, streamlined way to search for information about provider networks across plans.” His recommendation to customers: Call all of your docs to ask in the event that they’re collaborating in a plan you’re contemplating. (Make certain you might have your plan quantity once you do, as a result of a single firm could supply a number of plans in your market.)

Making issues much more troublesome: Plans can drop physicians or hospitals from their networks through the yr, leaving members with out entry to trusted sources of care.

A new report discloses information concerning the dimension of Medicare Advantage plans’ doctor networks for the primary time. It finds that, on common, Medicare Advantage HMOs included 42 % of physicians in a county of their networks whereas PPOs included 57 %. Altogether, 35 % of Medicare Advantage members are in plans with slender doctor networks, which are typically the most affordable plans.

Although this information highlights the alternatives that seniors have with regard to physicians, it doesn’t converse to the wait time they might encounter in accessing care, Jacobson mentioned, including that, to her data, this type of details about Medicare Advantage plans is just not publicly obtainable.

KHN’s protection associated to getting old & enhancing care of older adults is supported by The John A. Hartford Foundation.

We’re keen to listen to from readers about questions you’d like answered, issues you’ve been having along with your care and recommendation you want in coping with the well being care system. Visit to submit your requests or suggestions.

Medicare, Navigating Aging


Most Popular features the latest multimedia technologies, from live video streaming to audio packages to searchable archives of news features and background information. The site is updated continuously throughout the day.

Copyright © 2017 Breaking Express, Green Media Corporation

To Top