Judith Graham
Every 12 months, practically 2 million folks on Medicare — most of them older adults — go to a talented nursing facility to get well after a hospitalization. But selecting the power may be daunting, in keeping with an rising physique of analysis.
Typically, a nurse or a social employee arms out a listing of services a day or two — typically hours — earlier than a affected person is because of depart. The record usually lacks such important data because the companies supplied or how the services carry out on numerous measures of care high quality.
Families scramble to make calls and, if they will discover the time, go to a number of locations. Usually they’re undecided what the plan of care is (what is going to restoration entail? how lengthy will that take?) or what to anticipate (will nurses and docs be available? how a lot remedy will there be?).
If requested for a suggestion, hospital staffers usually refuse, citing authorities rules that prohibit hospitals from steering sufferers to explicit services and that assure sufferers free selection of medical suppliers. (This is true just for older adults with conventional Medicare; non-public Medicare Advantage plans can direct members to suppliers of their networks.)
“The reality is that we leave patients and families without good guidance at a really vulnerable point in their care trajectory,” stated Dr. Robert Burke, an assistant professor of medication on the University of Pennsylvania’s Perelman School of Medicine.
Amid stress and confusion, older adults and their households incessantly make lower than optimum decisions. According to a 2018 report from the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC), an unbiased company that advises Congress on Medicare, practically 84% of Medicare beneficiaries who go to a talented nursing facility (SNF) after a hospital keep might have chosen a higher-rated supplier inside a 15-mile radius. On common, MedPAC famous, hospitals refer sufferers needing short-term rehabilitation to 34 services. (Fewer choices can be found in rural areas.)
Where older adults go is necessary “because the quality of care varies widely among providers,” MedPAC’s report notes, and this impacts how absolutely folks get well from surgical procedures or diseases, whether or not they expertise issues akin to infections or treatment mix-ups, and whether or not they find yourself going residence or to a nursing residence for long-term care, amongst different elements.
A recently completed series of reports from the United Hospital Fund in New York City highlights how poorly older adults are served throughout this decision-making course of. In focus teams, households described feeling excluded from selections about post-hospital care and reported that web sites akin to Medicare’s Nursing Home Compare, which charges services by high quality of care and different efficiency standards, weren’t really useful, simple to make use of or particularly useful.
What do older adults and members of the family have to know earlier than deciding on a rehab facility after a hospital keep? Recent educational analysis, coverage stories and interviews with specialists elucidate a number of themes.
The Basics
Who wants post-hospital care in a rehabilitation heart? Surprisingly, there are not any definitive pointers for physicians or discharge planners. But older adults who’ve issue strolling or taking good care of themselves, have complicated medical circumstances and sophisticated treatment regimens, want shut monitoring or don’t have caregiver help are sometimes thought-about candidates for this sort of care, in keeping with Kathryn Bowles, professor of nursing on the University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing.
Medicare can pay for short-term rehabilitation at SNFs underneath two circumstances: (1) if an older grownup has had an inpatient hospital keep of no less than three days; and (2) if an older grownup wants bodily, occupational or speech/language remedy no less than 5 days every week or expert nursing care seven days every week.
Be certain to test your standing, as a result of not on a regular basis you spend in a hospital counts as an inpatient keep; typically, sufferers are labeled as being in “observation care,” which doesn’t rely towards this three-day requirement.
Traditional Medicare pays the total value of a semiprivate room and remedy at a talented nursing facility for as much as 20 days. Between 21 and 100 days, sufferers pay a coinsurance charge of $170.50 per day. After 100 days, a affected person turns into accountable for the total day by day cost — a mean $400 a day. Private Medicare Advantage plans could have different cost-sharing requirements.
Nationally, the typical keep for rehabilitation is about 25 days, in keeping with a recent editorial on selecting post-hospital care within the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.
Quality Varies Widely
In its 2018 report, MedPAC documented massive variations within the high quality of care supplied by SNFs. Notably, services with the worst efficiency had been twice as more likely to readmit sufferers to the hospital as these with the most effective efficiency. (Readmissions put sufferers liable to a number of issues. This measure utilized solely to readmissions deemed probably avoidable.) Patients on the best-performing services had been more likely to be discharged again residence and to regain the flexibility to maneuver round than these on the worst-performing services.
In April, for the primary time, Medicare’s Nursing Home Compare web site is separating out efficiency measures for short-term stays in SNFs, for people who find themselves recovering after a hospitalization, and long-term stays, for folks with extreme, persistent, debilitating circumstances.
Seven measures for short-term stays can be included: the portion of sufferers who expertise an enchancment of their functioning (akin to the flexibility to stroll), return residence to the neighborhood, are readmitted to the hospital, go to the emergency room, get new prescriptions for antipsychotic medicines, have ache properly managed, and are adequately handled for bedsores, in keeping with Dr. David Gifford, senior vp for high quality and regulatory affairs on the American Health Care Association, which represents nursing properties and assisted residing facilities. There may also be a separate “star rating” for short-term stays — an total indicator of high quality.
Questions To Ask
Before making a choice on post-hospital care, older adults and members of the family ought to tackle the next points:
Your post-hospital wants. Bowles, who has studied what kind of information patients and families find valuable, suggests folks ask: What are my wants going to be through the post-hospital interval? What type of assist can be wanted, and for about how lengthy?
Dr. Lena Chen, an affiliate professor of inside drugs on the University of Michigan who has revealed research analyzing large variations in spending on post-acute care after a hospitalization, suggests asking: What is my anticipated restoration, and what do you suppose probably the most tough components of it may be?
What the SNF offers. Bowles additionally suggests folks ask why the SNF is being really useful as an alternative of residence well being care. How will the SNF meet my wants, particularly? What type of medical care and remedy will I get there? From whom and the way usually?
Carol Levine, who directs the United Hospital Fund’s Families and Health Care Project, means that sufferers and households search out particulars about services. Is a health care provider available? (New research suggests 10% of sufferers in expert nursing services are by no means seen by a doctor, nurse practitioner or doctor assistant.) What type of gear and specialised companies are on-site? Can the power accommodate folks with cognitive points or who want dialysis, as an example?
Getting data early. Dr. Vincent Mor, professor of well being companies, coverage and follow at Brown University’s School of Public Health, stated sufferers and households ought to insist on seeing a discharge planner quickly after getting into the hospital and begin the planning course of early. When a planner comes by, “say, ‘I don’t care about choices: Tell me, what do you think will be best for me?’ Be insistent,” he suggested.
Burke warns that docs don’t usually know which SNF is more likely to be the most effective match for a specific affected person — a subject he has written about. He means that older adults or their households insist they be given time to contact services in the event that they really feel rushed. While there’s appreciable strain to discharge sufferers rapidly, there’s additionally a requirement that hospital discharges be secure, Burke famous. “If we’re waiting for a family to tell us which facility they want a patient to go to, we can’t make a referral or discharge the patient,” he stated.
We’re keen to listen to from readers about questions you’d like answered, issues you’ve been having along with your care and recommendation you want in coping with the well being care system. Visit khn.org/columnists to submit your requests or ideas.
Kaiser Health News (KHN) is a nationwide well being coverage information service. It is an editorially unbiased program of the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation which isn’t affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.
