[UPDATED at 1:45 p.m. ET]
Health insurers that deal with hundreds of thousands of seniors have overcharged Medicare by almost $30 billion the past three years alone, however federal officers say they’re transferring forward with long-delayed plans to recoup not less than a part of the cash.
Officials have identified for years that some Medicare Advantage plans overbill the federal government by exaggerating how sick their sufferers are or by charging Medicare for treating critical medical situations they can’t show their sufferers have.
Getting refunds from the well being plans has proved daunting, nonetheless. Officials with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services repeatedly have postponed, or backed off, efforts to crack down on billing abuses and errors by the more and more in style Medicare Advantage well being plans provided by personal well being insurers beneath contract with Medicare. Today, such plans deal with over 22 million seniors, greater than 1 in three individuals on Medicare.
Now CMS is making an attempt once more, proposing a collection of enhanced audits tailor-made to claw again $1 billion in Medicare Advantage overpayments by 2020 — only a tenth of what it estimates the plans overcharge the federal government in a given yr.
At the identical time, the Department of Health and Human Services Inspector General’s Office has launched a separate nationwide spherical of Medicare Advantage audits.
Subscribe to KHN’s free Morning Briefing.
As in previous years, such scrutiny faces an onslaught of criticism from the insurance coverage trade, which argues the CMS audits particularly are technically unsound and unfair and will jeopardize medical providers for seniors.
America’s Health Insurance Plans, an trade commerce group, blasted the CMS audit design when particulars emerged final fall, calling it “fatally flawed.”
Insurer Cigna Corp. warned in a May financial filing: “If adopted in its current form, [the audits] could have a detrimental impact” on all Medicare Advantage plans and “affect the ability of plans to deliver high quality care.”
But former Sen. Claire McCaskill, a Missouri Democrat who now works as a political analyst, mentioned officers should transfer previous highly effective lobbying efforts to carry well being insurers accountable and demand refunds for “inappropriate” billings.
“There’s a lot of things that could cause Medicare to go broke. This would be one of the contributing factors,” she mentioned. “Ten billion dollars a year is real money.”
Catching Overbilling With A Wider Net
In the overpayment dispute, well being plans need CMS to reduce — if not kill off — an enhanced audit device that, for the primary time, may drive insurers to cough up hundreds of thousands in improper funds they’ve acquired.
For over a decade, audits have been little greater than an irritant to insurers as a result of most plans go years with out being chosen for assessment and sometimes pay just a few hundred thousand dollars in refunds as a consequence. When auditors uncover errors within the medical data of sufferers they paid the businesses to deal with, CMS has merely required a rebate for these sufferers for simply the yr audited — comparatively small sums for plans with hundreds of members.
The newest CMS proposal would increase these stakes enormously by extrapolating error charges present in a random pattern of 200 sufferers to the plan’s full membership — a way anticipated to set off many multimillion-dollar penalties. Though controversial, extrapolation is frequent in medical fraud investigations — aside from investigations into Medicare Advantage. Since 2007, the trade has efficiently challenged the extrapolation methodology and, consequently, largely avoided accountability for pervasive billing errors.
“The public has a substantial interest in the recoupment of millions of dollars of public money improperly paid to health insurers,” CMS wrote in a Federal Register discover late final yr asserting its renewed try at utilizing extrapolation.
Penalties In Limbo
In a written response to questions posed by Kaiser Health News, CMS officers mentioned the company has already carried out 90 of these enhanced audits for funds made in 2011, 2012 and 2013 — and expects to gather $650 million in extrapolated penalties consequently.
Though that determine displays solely a minute proportion of precise losses to taxpayers from overpayments, it will be an enormous escalation for CMS. Previous Medicare Advantage audits have recouped a complete of about $14 million, far lower than it price to conduct them, federal data present.
Though CMS has disclosed the names of the well being plans within the crossfire, it has not but informed them how a lot every owes, officers mentioned. CMS declined to say when, or if, they’d make the outcomes public.
This yr, CMS is beginning audits for 2014 and 2015, 30 per yr, focusing on about 5% of the 600 plans yearly.
This spring, CMS introduced it will extend till the top of August the audit proposal’s public remark interval, which was supposed to finish in April. That might be a sign the company could be trying extra carefully at trade objections.
Health care trade guide Jessica Smith mentioned CMS could be taking further time to ensure the audit protocol can cross muster. “Once they have their ducks in a row, CMS will come back hard at the health plans. There is so much money tied to this.”
But Sean Creighton, a former senior CMS official who now advises the trade for well being care guide Avalere Health, mentioned cost error charges have been dropping as a result of many well being plans “are trying as hard as they can to become compliant.”
Still, audits are persevering with to seek out errors. The first HHS inspector common audit, launched in late April, discovered that Missouri-based Essence Healthcare Inc. had didn’t justify charges for dozens of sufferers it had handled for strokes or melancholy. Essence denied any wrongdoing however agreed it ought to refund $158,904 in overcharges for these sufferers and ferret out every other errors.
Essence additionally faces a pending whistleblower swimsuit filed by Charles Rasmussen, a Branson, Mo., physician who alleges the well being plan illegally boosted income by overstating the severity of sufferers’ medical situations. Essence has known as the allegations “wholly without merit” and “baseless.”
Essence began as a St. Louis doctor group, then grew right into a broader holding firm in 2007 backed by distinguished Silicon Valley enterprise capitalist John Doerr along with his brother, St. Louis physician and software program designer Thomas Doerr. Neither would touch upon the allegations.
How We Got Here
CMS makes use of a billing formulation known as a “risk score” to pay for every Medicare Advantage member. The formulation pays increased charges for sicker sufferers than for individuals in good well being.
Congress accredited threat scoring in 2003 to make sure well being plans didn’t draw back from taking sick sufferers who may incur higher-than-usual prices from hospitals and different medical amenities. But some insurers shortly discovered ways to spice up threat scores — and their revenues.
In 2007, after a number of years of operating Medicare Advantage as what one CMS official dubbed an “honor system,” the company launched “Risk Adjustment Data Validation,” or RADV, audits. The concept was to chop down on undeserved funds that price CMS almost $30 billion over the previous three years.
The audits of 37 well being plans revealed that on common auditors may affirm simply 60% of the greater than 20,000 medical situations CMS had paid the plans to deal with.
Extra funds to plans that had claimed a few of its diabetic sufferers had issues, resembling eye or kidney issues, have been diminished or invalidated in almost half the circumstances. The overpayments exceeded $10,000 a yr for greater than 150 sufferers, although well being plans disputed among the findings.
But CMS saved the findings beneath wraps till the Center for Public Integrity, an investigative journalism group, sued the company beneath the Freedom of Information Act to make them public.
Despite the alarming outcomes, CMS carried out no audits for funds made throughout 2008, 2009 and 2010 as they confronted trade backlash over CMS’ authority to conduct them, and the specter of extrapolated repayments. Some contained in the company additionally nervous that well being plans would abandon the Medicare Advantage program if CMS pressed them too onerous, data launched via the FOIA lawsuit present.
CMS officers resumed the audits for 2011 and anticipated to complete them and assess penalties by the top of 2016. That has but to occur amid the persevering with protests from the trade. Insurers need CMS to regulate downward any extrapolated penalties to account for coding errors that exist in normal Medicare. CMS stands behind its methodology — not less than for now.
At a minimal, argues AHIP, the well being insurers affiliation, CMS ought to again off extrapolation for the 90 audits for 2011-13. Should CMS agree, it will write off greater than half a billion dollars that might be recovered for the U.S. Treasury.
[Correction: This story was updated at 1:45 p.m. ET to remove a reference to America’s Health Insurance Plans’ view on how the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services should handle audits from 2014 and beyond.]
Fred Schulte: email@example.com”>firstname.lastname@example.org, @fredschulte
Lauren Weber: LaurenW@kff.org”>LaurenW@kff.org, @LaurenWeberHP